Jennifer Blanton

Mastering Email Marketing to Drive Rewards Program Engagement

In our crowded digital landscape, email remains one of the most powerful channels for reaching and engaging existing customers. When it comes to promoting your brand's shopping rewards program, well-crafted email campaigns can be the key to driving awareness, participation, and loyalty. 

By delivering well-built, value-driven content directly to your subscribers' inboxes, you can drive increased participation and engagement in your rewards program.

How To Build an Email for the Way Customers Read

Typically, people read email in 3 stages:

1) The primary read

This is essentially the first impression, when you must capture their attention. You typically have only a few seconds, often less than 5 seconds. 

email-anatomy-primary-readFor the primary read, the subject line and initial content need to be engaging and relevant to make the reader want to continue reading. First impressions are crucial in email marketing!

2) The secondary read

Next is the secondary read. If you’ve been successful in capturing a reader's attention in the primary read, they may continue to scroll.

The body of your email should include interesting content that will keep them engaged. 

In a rewards program email, this area is a great place to highlight merchants relevant to the email’s theme. 

3) The tertiary read

Finally, you have the tertiary read. This is an optional section for the email allowing for the opportunity for another CTA. Perhaps to drive traffic to other content on your site related to the program.



Checklist to Build Engaging Rewards Program Emails

Crafting an email that captures attention and compels action requires a strategic approach. As we’ve noted above, every element, from the subject line to the call-to-action (CTA), plays a crucial role in the email's success. 

Here is a list of things to pay attention to so you make the most of each element:

  • Compelling Subject Line: As the first thing your subscribers see, the subject line sets the tone and can make or break your open rates. Keep it concise, engaging, and relevant to the email's content.
  • Eye-Catching Design: Invest in an attractive, mobile-optimized design that aligns with your brand's visual identity. Use high-quality images, graphics, and a clean layout to create an enjoyable reading experience.
  • Engaging Content: Whether you're highlighting special offers, new reward tiers, or exclusive benefits, ensure your content is focused and relevant. Use clear, benefit-driven language and break up text with visuals to maintain reader interest.
  • Prominent CTAs: Include clear and prominent CTAs that guide subscribers toward the desired action, such as enrolling in the program, redeeming rewards, or making a purchase.
  • Personalization: Leverage subscriber data to personalize content, addressing readers by name and tailoring recommendations based on their interests and behaviors. This level of personalization can significantly boost engagement.
  • Consistent Branding: Maintain a consistent brand experience by incorporating your logo, color palette, typography, and visual style throughout the email. This reinforces brand recognition and builds trust.
  • Valuable Incentives: Offer exclusive promotions, discounts, or early access to rewards to incentivize subscribers to engage with your program actively.
  • Social Media Integration: Include links to your social media channels, encouraging subscribers to connect with your brand across multiple touchpoints.
  • Analytics and Optimization: Regularly analyze performance metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversion data. Use these insights to refine your content, timing, and targeting strategies continuously.


Leveraging email marketing to promote your rewards program requires a strategic approach. By combining compelling content, attractive design, and valuable incentives, you can create a seamless and engaging experience that drives program participation.

Remember, successful email campaigns are an ongoing effort. Continuously analyze performance, gather customer feedback, and iterate your strategies to ensure your rewards program marketing emails remain fresh, relevant, and impactful.


Give your customers the cashback they want

Schedule a demo

Published by Jennifer Blanton June 4, 2024
Jennifer Blanton